Shorter treatments are safe and effective for children with minimal tuberculosis
26 Oct 2020
Treatment times for children with minimal tuberculosis (TB) can be safely reduced from six months to four months, according to the results of the SHINE trial, presented on 24 October at The Union World Conference on Lung Health.
SHINE is the first randomised controlled trial to assess the length of treatment needed for children with TB. Until now, treatment for children with TB has been based on trials in adults. However, two thirds of children with TB have a less severe form of the disease. This led researchers to run the SHINE trial, to find out if these children could have a shorter treatment.
More than a million children develop TB each year, and more than 205,000 children die from the disease. However, children with TB generally do well if they are diagnosed and treated.
TB treatments involve taking a combination of drugs for several months. Current guidelines recommend that children with drug-sensitive TB are treated for six months. However, taking several pills every day for six months can be difficult for children and carers. Some TB drugs interact with other drugs, such as those used for treating HIV, making treatment even more complicated. Reducing the length of time children need to take pills for could make treatment easier for children and carers, as well as reducing costs to patients and the health system.
The SHINE trial took place in South Africa, Uganda, Zambia and India. 1204 children with minimal TB took part in the trial. Minimal TB is TB that is smear negative (so cannot be detected in sputum using a microscope) and non-severe. They were randomised to receive either:
- six months of treatment, with eight weeks of the drugs isoniazid, rifampicin, pyrazinamide (and ethambutol in some countries, depending on national guidelines), followed by 16 weeks of isoniazid and rifampicin
- four months of treatment, with eight weeks of the drugs isoniazid, rifampicin, pyrazinamide (and ethambutol in some countries, depending on national guidelines), followed by eight weeks of isoniazid and rifampicin
Children in the trial were followed up for 72 weeks.
The SHINE results show that children with minimal TB do very well on treatment. 93% of children were successfully treated and confirmed alive and well at the end of the trial. Less than 3% of children in the trial had unfavourable outcomes.
SHINE found that the four month treatment was as good as the standard six month treatment for children with minimal TB. There was no difference between the six months and four months groups in terms of proportion with an unfavourable outcome, or deaths. Side-effects related to treatment were few, and similar across both groups.
These results mean that around two thirds of children could potentially be safely and effectively treated with four months of treatment rather than six months. The findings from this study have the potential to update current guidelines; the World Health Organization (WHO) has announced that the findings will contribute to their ongoing processes to refine current policy recommendations.
SHINE also demonstrates that it is possible to do high quality randomised controlled trials in children with TB.